• Sunday brunch buffet, desserts
    20 Photos
  • Sunday brunch buffet $13.99 adults, $8.99 kids
    20 Photos
  • Pot roast, fantastic
    20 Photos

The Old Feed Mill

62 reviews on
American Restaurant
·$$
Closed. Will open today at 11:00 AM·11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Thu:4:30 PM - 8:00 PM
  • Fri:11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Sat:11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Sun:10:00 AM - 2:30 PM
The Old Feed Mill is known for its Fork Tender Pot Roast. Midwest Living featured it in their article: A Taste of Comfort". Jerry Minnich a food reviewer said... more
The Old Feed Mill is known for its Fork Tender Pot Roast. Midwest Living featured it in their article: A Taste of Comfort". Jerry Minnich a food reviewer said "I have never had a better pot roast-Ever so slowly cooked beef yields easily to the fork. Unsullied by unwanted seasonings but graced by dark, rich, brown pan gravy, this is indeed a pot roast for the gods." The other signature dish is cider roast chicken, steeped in apple cider, crusted with fresh herbs and roasted until moist and golden. Originally a flour mill, wheat and rye grown locally is stone ground on site for the honey wheat bread brought to the table.... less
Is this your business?

Reviews

  • Diane D.
    2/27/2020
    This is our not-so-fancy date night place. We went on Valentines Day, and the special menu was a treat! Our faves are pot roast, fish fry, meatloaf, and the mushroom pastry. Entrées come with...more
  • Tedd R.
    Tedd R.
    8/11/2019
    Ample parking for when Robert Irwin and his crew make a much needed visit. Our group of seven (one infant) had the following: Meatloaf which might have been OK if not slathered with some gastly...more
  • Rebecca V.
    Rebecca V.
    9/7/2019
    Not vegetarian friendly. Very basic meat/potatoes. Cute but sterile atmosphere. Would it hurt to have some soft music playing? Indifferent, impersonal service.more
  • Laurie J.
    Laurie J.
    2/9/2019
    We stopped by for lunch. Beautiful old building. Found out it is not the original structure, but after a fire it was rebuilt in 1899. Yeah it's old. 12 x12 x40 wood beams in excellent...more
  • Janice J.
    Janice J.
    4/3/2018
    Came here for lunch the Saturday before Easter. I'm not sure if it was the weather or the fact that people were saving their appetites for Easter, but there was only one other table in the entire...more