Search results
Jan 11, 2022 · It is a thumbprint cookie with an odd, very tender, but almost chewy texture that is topped with a great pile of dense frosting. The cookie part always has sprinkles (known locally as “jimmies”), which are color coded to match the frosting.
- I Don’T Have Cake Flour, What Can I use?
- Do I Have to Use The Shortening?
- Can I Use Sprinkles Instead of Jimmies?
- Do I Need Both Almond and Vanilla Extracts?
- GeneratedCaptionsTabForHeroSec
Making your own cake flour is super easy! Simply add 2 tablespoons of cornstarch to 2 cups of all purpose flour and mix well.
If you want your cookies to be firm yet tender you really need to add the shortening. The first batch I made substituted butter for the shortening and they just weren’t the same. I use Crisco shortening and it works so well in this recipe.
Ok can you use sprinkles? Yes. Will it be the same? No because jimmies are what real Pittsburghers use. I like that jimmies hold their shape and color in the oven where sprinkles can melt into the dough. However you can use sprinkles if that’s what you have at home.
If you want the flavor of the actual cookie and buttercream from Arcade Bakery you need to use both. If you don’t care if the flavor is a little off you can use just one or the other. Be careful when using almond extract as it is a very strong flavor. Only use the tiny bit mentioned in the recipe. I used Taylor & Colledge extract pastes in this rec...
Learn how to make the famous Kaufmann's Thumbprint Cookies from Pittsburgh, a tender cookie with buttercream frosting. Follow the recipe with tips, ingredients, and photos.
- (23)
- 24
- Cookies
Learn how to make the best chocolate chip cookies with this easy recipe. Find tips on ingredients, baking, freezing, and storing Kaufmann Thumbprint Cookies.
- Dessert
- 190
- American
Roll in the sprinkles or nuts. Then press down with your thumb (or something with a round edge, like a rolling pin) to form a thumbprint in the middle. Chill them on baking sheets in the refrigerator for 10 minutes. Bake the cookies for 15 minutes or until lightly golden on the bottoms.
Dec 3, 2021 · Learn how cookies are more than ingredients, they are a way to share love and honor family traditions during the Christmas season. Find out how to make Kaufmann's thumbprints and other festive cookies, and how to give them as gifts or donate them to those in need.
These cookies were sold at the Arcade Bakery at the Kaufmann's downtown Pittsburgh location. I used the recipe from The Wedding Cookie Table Community on Fa...
- 10 min
- 2.7K
- Melissa Carnack
People also ask
How do I make Kaufmann thumbprint cookies?
How do you make a thumbprint Cookie?
How do you make Pittsburgh thumbprint cookies?
Can you freeze Kaufmann thumbprint cookie dough?
The Fallingwater PB&J Thumbprint Cookie. From the kitchen at Fallingwater, these delicious shortbread cookies filled to the brim with jam and covered in a decadent peanut butter frosting, these are perfect for any celebration – large or small. This recipe makes 12-18 cookies. Thumprint Cookie Ingredients. ½ cup sugar; ¼ teaspoon salt
