Search results
Feb 28, 2012 · 2. The "4 lights" shtick is directly cribbed from the "4 fingers" scene in George Orwell's "1984". In 1984, the torturer makes it clear that the point is not to get the victim to agree that there are 5 lights. In fact, at one point the victim, Winston Smith, readily agrees with his torturer, only to be tortured some more.
- The torture scene in this episode is nearly verbatim from Nineteen Eighty-Four 's "2 + 2 = 5" . In the novel, the slogan is a primary example of...
- The point of this was simply to "break" Picard with a meaningless, symbolic victory. Agreeing that there are five lights instead of four is, on the...
- Why the lights? It's like the "third degree" in old cop movies. In those, often someone was forced to sit in a dark room and made to stare at a br...
- It's a tactic to force Picard to accept what Madred tells him is reality rather than what his senses tell him is reality. (In short, to break Pi...
- You could also ask why Madred just didn't turn on the pain device and not turn it off until Picard told him what he wanted. The answer is, as allu...
- Coercion is a basic tactic in psychological operations. Once you have coerced your victim to do something simple like state a known falsehood, the...
- The "4 lights" shtick is directly cribbed from the "4 fingers" scene in George Orwell's "1984". In 1984, the torturer makes it clear that the poin...
- I kind of liked the idea that Madred WAS the fifth light. While I can't deny the 1984 reference, because that's pretty epic, I think the reasoning...
- Madred and Picard waged a war against each other. To use a historical analogy, the "five" lights were like Caesar's river Rubicon. Totally meaningl...
Dec 14, 2021 · The Four Lights. “There are four lights!”. Those are the final words Captain Jean-Luc Picard shouts out to his torturer, Gul Madred. Good prevails over evil and all is well with the world. And yet, in the epilogue to the story our hero acknowledges that he was ready to capitulate, prepared to recognize a lie as truth: it was the only way to ...
There were four lights. The torturer wanted him to say that there were five lights as that would be a signal that Picard was now accepting the tortures reality. It's based off a concept from Orwell's 1984, where another torture says that they can make someone believe 2 + 2 = 5. Reply.
Star Trek: The Next Generation. ) " Chain of Command " is a two-part episode of the American science fiction television series Star Trek: The Next Generation. It aired as the 10th and 11th episodes of the sixth season, the 136th and 137th episodes of the series. Set in the 24th century, the series follows the adventures of the Starfleet crew of ...
- Frank Abatemarco (Part I)
- Jay Chattaway
- Frank Abatemarco (Part II)
People also ask
Which Star Trek episode has the 'four lights'?
How many lights are there in 'Star Trek'?
Why are there 4 lights in Star Trek 2 & Nero?
What is the best scene in Star Trek 'The next generation'?
Dec 12, 2023 · Yet, the budget was always a problem, and one such penny-pinching episode became one of TNG and Patrick Stewart's most beloved episodes, in which he declares "There are four lights!" But it almost didn't happen. The two-part Season 6 episode "Chain of Command" is notable for many reasons, not the least of which is that it prompted Deanna Troi ...
The third book in Wallace Moore's "Balzan of the Cat People" pulp SF series, 1975's "The Lights of Zetar," was apparently an homage to this episode. Star Trek Novel #42, Memory Prime by Gar and Judith Reeves-Stevens, continues the story of Romaine on Memory Prime, the successor to Memory Alpha.
