Search results
Jan 20, 2012 · Overruled: When an objection is overruled, the judge has determined the objection is invalid. The question may stand. The witness must then answer the question. A shorthand way to remember this is Overruled = Ongoing, as in the witness may continue as if the objection never occurred. Hope this helps!
People also ask
What happens if a judge overrules a question?
What happens if an objection is overruled?
What does it mean if a judge sustains an objection?
What happens when an attorney makes an objection?
A judge “overruling the objection” means that the judge does not agree with your objection. The overruling of an objection means that the question may “stand.” In legal terms, this means that the witness still has to answer the question.
May 6, 2024 · The judge can either "overrule" or "sustain" the objection. When the judge overrules an objection, the judge believes the evidence was properly admitted, or the question was correct. The trial can proceed without further action.
Mar 20, 2024 · Two terms frequently heard during courtroom proceedings are “overruled” and “sustained.”. These words represent rulings made by a judge in response to objections raised during a trial. Let’s dissect what they mean and how they differ.
- (14)
- This Happens in Every Civil Trial Here in New York.
- I'm Talking About Objections.
- Maybe The Question Is Not Phrased properly.
- The Judge Has Three Choices on How He Can Rule.
- It Might Mean That The Attorney Is Harassing The Witness.
It doesn't matter whether it's a car accident trial. It doesn't matter whether it's a medical malpractice trial. It doesn't matter whether it's a wrongful death trial. It will happen every single trial. Guaranteed. What am I talking about? Simple.
Objections made during the course of trial. Objections made during questioning. Objections made when evidence is offered. Objections made when an attorney says something. Objections are often made during trial. An objection is raised any time an attorney believes something is improper.
Maybe the question assumes facts that are not in evidence. Maybe the attorney is putting words into the witness' mouth and now it's presented as a leading question. Maybe the records that are being offered into evidence are not true and accurate photocopies of the original. Maybe the medical expert that the defense has put on is not truly qualified...
He can agree with the attorney who is making the objection. He can disagree with the attorney who's making the objection. Or, he can decide that he needs more information and will ask for legal briefs from the attorneys. Actually, there's a fourth option... The judge can defer his ruling until a later time or until after the jury has reached a verd...
It might mean that the attorney is asking something that is not relevant to the legal issues in the case. There could be many reasons to raise an objection and just as important, there could be many reasons why the judge would not allow the attorney to ask a particular question. On the other hand, if the judge disagrees with the attorney who is mak...
Whenever a lawyer objects to an action taken by his opposing attorney, the presiding judge has two options―either to agree with the objection and ‘sustain’ it, or to ‘overrule’ the said objection and allow the opposing lawyer to get on with whatever he is trying to get at.
Jun 18, 2024 · If the judge agrees with the objection, they will say ‘Objection Sustained.’ A sustained objection can protect the claim as it is presented to the trial judge. But even an objection overruled has a purpose, as it allows the issue to be considered by the appellate court.
